Where to Live on Long Island for a Wellness-First Lifestyle

If you’ve ever thought, “I love Long Island, but I’d also like to not age five years every time I hit the LIE,”—you’re not alone. In 2025, more buyers and renters are looking for places where self-care isn’t just a spa day, but part of daily life. From yoga-friendly neighborhoods to communities where your step count soars without the stress, wellness living is no longer a luxury—it’s a necessity—and Long Island, surprisingly, is getting in on the trend.

So where can you plant roots, breathe deeply, and still find your zen without giving up your New York hustle? Here are the top spots where wellness is baked into the lifestyle—and maybe even gluten-free.

1. Great Neck: Clean Air and Cultured Calm

Great Neck blends upscale suburban life with access to trails, water views, and community centers that offer everything from tai chi to pickleball. The area has a high concentration of wellness clinics, top-tier gyms, and yes—even green juice that doesn’t taste like regret. With a median home price hovering around $1.3M and homes selling at a healthy pace in Q2 2025, Great Neck proves that zen can come with a ZIP code—just don’t expect it to be cheap.

2. Garden City: Walkability with Whole Foods Energy

This isn’t your typical commuter suburb. Garden City has well-maintained walking paths, farmers markets, and boutique fitness studios sprinkled between upscale homes. It's ideal for anyone who wants to swap noise pollution for bird chirps without losing the convenience of great schools and direct rail access. And with prices leveling out post-COVID boom, it’s a smart time to buy before another wave of burnt-out city folks rediscovers its charm.

3. Babylon Village: Wellness with Waterfront Vibes

With its charming downtown and boardwalk feel, Babylon Village lets you paddleboard before lunch and hit a community yoga class after. The town leans into holistic living with health-minded cafes, nature preserves, and a vibe that says, "Let’s take things down a notch—but make it stylish." Median prices are competitive compared to the Hamptons, and you still get sunrise views that don’t require a trust fund.

4. Setauket: Nature-Filled Serenity That’s Actually Affordable

Tucked away in Brookhaven, Setauket offers a slice of quiet with access to beaches, wooded trails, and an underrated arts scene. Average home values here have remained steady with a slight uptick in wellness-minded transplants. It's also got a strong sense of community and local businesses that support sustainable and mindful living. Think less traffic, more tree canopy, and nobody yelling at you over a parking spot.

5. Bellmore: Balanced Living on a Budget

Want wellness but still need to afford groceries? Bellmore is your sweet spot. With bike trails, waterfront parks, and plenty of fresh food markets, it’s wellness that won’t wipe out your wallet. It's a solid choice for young families, remote workers, or anyone who just wants a healthy routine with a side of real estate sanity. Homes here remain accessible under $700K with high livability scores.

6. Huntington: Vibrant, Artsy, and Wellness-Curious

Huntington isn’t just for theatergoers and antique shoppers. It’s got an expanding network of fitness studios, mindfulness workshops, and organic cafes that make it a rising player in the wellness game. With community events and waterfront parks, it balances hustle with health like a local yogi who also happens to run a tech startup. The downtown real estate market is holding strong, and wellness-centered developments are drawing attention.

7. Rockville Centre: Modern Convenience, Stress-Free Commutes

If being well means not losing your mind every weekday morning, Rockville Centre has your back. It offers quick train access to Manhattan, walkable downtowns, and a growing number of boutique health practices—from Pilates to acupuncture. Homes average in the high $700Ks, but the value lies in cutting your cortisol levels during your daily grind.

Wellness Is the New Status Symbol

In a post-pandemic world, the idea of “making it” is less about flashy cars and more about having a lifestyle that doesn’t require a chiropractor and three therapists. Living well is living smart—and Long Island’s got neighborhoods that are finally catching up.

I’m Dean Miller, Long Island’s only AI-certified real estate agent. If you’re ready to drop the drama, level up your living, and find a home that supports your sanity, I’ve got the neighborhood—and the negotiating chops—to get it done. Let’s talk before someone else finds your future yoga mat view.