Massapequa Madness: Homes Are Hot, Inventory Is No

Let’s call it what it is—shopping for a home in Massapequa in 2025 feels like trying to win a ticket to a secret Taylor Swift show. It’s a blood sport. And if you’re a seller? Congratulations—you’re the new Beyoncé. This year’s numbers are in, and they’re telling a tale of sky-high demand, shockingly low inventory, and prices that make you question whether your childhood Monopoly skills can still save you.

Prices: Up, Up, and Nope—Still Up

The average sales price jumped from $748,167 in June 2024 to $872,806 in June 2025. That’s a 17% increase. If you blinked, you missed $125K. Median sales prices weren’t far behind, up 21% to $830,000. Even the average price of pending homes rose 8%. So no, that fixer-upper with 70s wallpaper and a driveway the size of a yoga mat isn’t going for “cheap.”

Interest Rates Dipped... But Not Enough to Save You

Rates dropped 5%, down to 6.01%. Great news, right? Maybe—if there were actually homes to buy. The problem isn’t just affordability. It’s available. Pending listings are down 9%, and sold listings took a nosedive—57% fewer homes sold this June compared to last. Which begs the question: if no one can buy, is it still a seller’s market? Answer: Yes. But only for the lucky few who list.

Days on Market and Month Supply: The New Roller Coaster

Average days on market went from 34 to 42, which on paper looks like things are slowing. Spoiler alert—they’re not. It’s just that the inventory is so slim that buyers are being extra cautious and only leaping when the price-to-value ratio doesn’t feel like a dare. Supply dropped from 2.8 to 2.3 months. Translation: we’re scraping the bottom of the listing barrel.

Top Sales: Massapequa’s Million-Dollar Club Is Growing

A record ten homes sold for prices ranging from $810K to $1.3 million. Springdale Avenue and Adam Road W topped the list at $1.335M and $1.135M respectively. Yes, you read that right. Over a million bucks. In Massapequa. If your parents bought here in the 80s, they might be sitting on a goldmine—and hopefully not still storing Christmas decorations in the basement from Y2K.

Buyers, Sellers, and the Game of Timing

If you’re a buyer, here’s your reality check: get pre-approved and don’t hesitate. The homes are fewer, the competition is fierce, and your dream house is probably getting 11 offers before the ink dries on the listing. For sellers, this is your Super Bowl. But only if you’re ready to play—because selling high is great, unless you have to buy again five blocks away at the same inflated price.


CTA:

Thinking of selling before prices plateau—or worse, dip? Wondering if that dated ranch you’ve been living in is now worth the GDP of a small country? Dean Miller’s got your back. Call him before your neighbor’s “For Sale” sign makes you second guess everything. Because in this market, waiting isn’t just risky—it’s expensive.