Eat Fresh in Wantagh: Best Places for Fresh Fruits & Veggies

Wantagh may be famous for boardwalks and beaches and backyard BBQs—although if you're still thinking that fresh food equals grazing through a sprawling fluorescent-lit supermarket for no reason whatsoever, we have to have a talk. This South Shore treasure contains more fresh and local produce that most big-boxes would claim as "organic." It might not matter whether you're a die-hard CSA member or you're someone fed up with tomatoes that have the flavor of cardboard; these places will have you questioning your next shopping trip.

Here's where to shop for the genuine article—without preservatives, pretension, or pre-cut fruit in plastic containers.

1. Grossmann's Crossroads Farm in Malverne

Yes, it's a bit off of Wantagh. No, not far for anyone who's sat in Southern State traffic. This certified organic farm is a retro throwback to a time when fruit and vegetables really tasted like food. Shop weekend farm stands, talk to real farmers, and pick up both produce and a sense of mission.

2. Wantagh Farmers Market (Seasonal)

Hosted in the LIRR parking lot—nothing says Long Island like filling up your hatchback with heritage tomatoes as you weave in and out of train schedules. It's a seasonal crew of local heroes serving up farm-to-people freshness. Be there early to get your berries. We promise you, they disappear quicker than a parking spot along the beach on July 4th.

3. Stew Leonard's (East Meadow

Imagine if Disney and Costco got together and produced a child. This would be it. Animatronic cows, yes. Long Island-grown produce, also yes. The showmanship may be a little overwhelming, but the seasonal produce and vegetables are good. Good for families, and your kids won’t have to complain that there was nothing to do. Win-win.

4. Milburn Orchards (North Bellmore

A small but mighty stand offering newly picked corn, tomatoes, and berries as if on a mission to restore your senses. No hype for the sake of marketing—actual produce from actual farmers. Bonus: You might end up going home with some ideas for new recipes and a positive attitude.

5. Community Supported Agriculture or local CSAs

Here's how to shop like a pro. Join a CSA through Restoration Farm or Garden of Eve and receive a weekly fresh box. It's a mystery box and meal prep all in one. You'll learn about a new food or two each week—and how to prepare it without having to Google "is this food?"

6. Your Own Backyard (Seriously)

Raise your hand if you assumed gardening was only for elderly folks. Think again. DIY gardens are hot in Wantagh these days, and between starter kits and raised beds, your own garden has never been more within reach. No lines to wait in, no markup to pay, and your basil won't keel over in a plastic pot two days later.

7. Uncle Giuseppe’s Marketplace (Massape

Italian deli combined with a farm stand. Though not strictly local, Uncle G’s includes Long Island products in season and an ample supply of fresh food to impress your dinner party guests into believing you have a villa in Tuscany. Bonus: their mozzarella section is highly distracting.

8. Jones Beach Greenmarket Pop-Ups (Seasonal

Sun, surf, and spinach. These summertime greenmarket stands provide a double dose of vitamin D and locally cultivated kale. Bring a cooler if you're driving in from the beach—then you'll have a chance to load up on the way out.

9. Lidl (East Meadow & Massapequa)

You won't believe this. Lidl has snuck in a boost to its in-house local produce and isn't a farm stand by any means but does have a good amount of fresh produce that won't blow your budget. Dub it "budget gourmet" and dress up your Instagram captions.

Craving a fresher lifestyle—on your plate and in your neighborhood?

Wantagh isn’t a farm town, but it’s definitely fresher than you think. Between open-air markets, hyperlocal stands, CSAs, and even your own backyard, there are more ways than ever to eat like a legend without blowing your grocery budget.

Done with flavorless lettuce and overpriced berries? Let’s shop smarter. Save this list, grab a tote bag, and go experience real flavor—Wantagh-style. 

Dean Miller doesn’t just know Wantagh real estate—he knows where the real flavor lives. From backyard gardens to homes near your favorite farmers market, he’ll help you find a home that fits your lifestyle (and maybe room for that herb garden, too 🌱).

📞 Call, text, or DM Dean Miller today to talk homes, harvests, and where to plant your roots—literally.
Because in Wantagh, fresh starts aren’t just for vegetables. 🏡🥕