Golfing Greens: Long Island's Top Golf Courses Revealed (By the Numbers)

When most people think of Long Island, they envision sandy beaches, world-class bagels, or that never-ending traffic on the LIE. But for the true enthusiasts out there, Long Island represents something else entirely—a golfer’s paradise. With some of the country’s finest courses scattered across the island, Long Island boasts a rich golfing tradition, top-tier facilities, and enough challenge to keep both weekend warriors and serious players coming back for more.

But let’s get down to business. Golf on Long Island isn’t just about the sport—it’s about money, market dynamics, and, yes, some good old-fashioned real estate appreciation. Whether you’re swinging for par or searching for a new home near the links, this blog will take a look at the numbers driving Long Island’s golfing culture and why these greens are not just for tee times—they’re driving up property values too. Let’s take a swing, shall we?

Long Island's Golf Scene by the Numbers

First, let’s talk stats. According to the National Golf Foundation, Long Island is home to over 140 golf courses, ranging from elite private clubs to accessible public courses. In 2023 alone, the local golf industry generated a whopping $600 million in direct and indirect economic activity—yes, that’s $600 million just from golfers, their clubs, and maybe a few “19th hole” beverages.

The island has seen a 12% increase in golf participation over the last three years, driven by a surge in interest post-pandemic. As more people looked for safe outdoor activities, golf quickly became a favorite, with local courses reporting record numbers of tee times and lessons booked. Whether it’s retirees refining their short game or families introducing their kids to the sport, Long Island’s greens have never been more popular.

And then there’s real estate. Homes located near Long Island’s top golf courses have appreciated between 10-20% over the last decade, driven in large part by the allure of living close to some of the country’s most prestigious courses. But more on that later—first, let’s check out the courses themselves.

The Must-Play Courses on Long Island

For golfers, Long Island isn’t just a place to play—it’s a destination. Home to several top-ranked courses, Long Island attracts pros and amateurs alike from around the world. Here are the courses you absolutely must know about, whether you're swinging for the stars or just admiring from afar.

1. Shinnecock Hills Golf Club (Southampton)

Considered one of the most prestigious golf courses on the planet, Shinnecock Hills is a legend in its own right. Established in 1891, it’s one of the oldest golf clubs in America and regularly ranks among the top 10 courses in the world. Shinnecock Hills has hosted the U.S. Open five times, with its most recent appearance in 2018, bringing a major influx of tourism to the South Fork.

But here’s where the numbers get interesting: The prestige of Shinnecock Hills doesn’t just drive tourism; it drives real estate prices. Homes within a five-mile radius of the course have appreciated by an impressive 15% over the last decade, with some properties selling for upwards of $5 million. Why? Well, who wouldn’t want to live near golf royalty?

2. Bethpage Black (Farmingdale)

If there’s a public course that commands as much respect as its private counterparts, it’s Bethpage Black. Known for its brutal difficulty and iconic "Warning" sign at the first tee, Bethpage Black has hosted several major tournaments, including two U.S. Opens and the PGA Championship. And let’s not forget, it’s set to host the Ryder Cup in 2025. This challenging course is a bucket list item for many, even if it means walking away with a bruised ego.

Bethpage’s public nature makes it accessible, but don’t let that fool you—it generates serious economic activity. With over 300,000 rounds of golf played annually across its five courses, Bethpage contributes roughly $40 million a year to the local economy. And the surrounding area? Homes near Bethpage have appreciated 12% over the last five years, with buyers looking to snag a piece of land near one of the country’s most renowned public courses.

3. Maidstone Club (East Hampton)

East Hampton’s Maidstone Club is a private, oceanside course known for its exclusivity and its picturesque setting. Established in 1891, this club offers players not just a challenging round of golf, but stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean as they navigate its dunes and coastal landscapes.

For the lucky few who get to play here, Maidstone is an experience, but let’s talk about its real influence: real estate. Homes within a short distance of Maidstone command some of the highest prices on Long Island, with average home values around $4 million. The demand for real estate in East Hampton has been driven not just by the beach, but by the prestige of living near one of America’s finest courses.

4. Garden City Golf Club (Garden City)

Classic and understated, Garden City Golf Club is another gem of Long Island’s private club circuit. Established in 1899, this course retains much of its historical charm, with fast greens and a traditional layout. What makes Garden City unique is its old-school approach—this course hasn’t been over-commercialized or modernized, making it a throwback to a simpler era of golf.

That charm extends to the surrounding real estate. Homes near the Garden City Golf Club have seen 10% appreciation over the past five years. The appeal? Garden City is not only home to a great course, but also some of the best schools, restaurants, and a strong sense of community—making it one of the most desirable areas on Long Island.

5. Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course (Montauk)

For those who prefer public courses with breathtaking views, Montauk Downs is the ultimate destination. Designed by Robert Trent Jones Sr., this course offers stunning vistas of the Atlantic while delivering a challenging layout that keeps golfers coming back for more.

While Montauk is known for its summer tourism and surfing, Montauk Downs adds another layer to the local economy, contributing roughly $10 million annually in golf-related tourism. The scenic appeal of Montauk Downs has driven up property values in the area by 8-10% over the last five years, with many homebuyers looking to invest in Montauk’s dual appeal as both a coastal retreat and a golfer’s dream.

Golf’s Impact on Real Estate and Market Dynamics

So, what’s the connection between golf and real estate? It’s simple: location matters. Homes near golf courses—especially those with names like Shinnecock and Maidstone attached—tend to appreciate at a higher rate than other properties. Why? Because for many buyers, proximity to a prestigious course is more than just a perk—it’s a lifestyle.

Here’s a stat that might surprise you: According to Zillow, homes near top-tier golf courses on Long Island have appreciated by an average of 10-20% over the last decade. This trend has been particularly strong in areas like East Hampton and Southampton, where golf clubs and the luxury lifestyle are deeply intertwined.

Even public courses like Bethpage Black and Montauk Downs contribute to local property value increases, driven by both tourism and the desire to live near a recreational hotspot. And with golf participation continuing to rise, it’s likely that homes near these courses will only become more valuable in the coming years.

Tee Up Your Dream Home

Whether you’re looking to improve your short game, find a home with easy access to the greens, or simply want to live near some of the most beautiful golf courses in the country, Long Island is the place to be. The island’s golf courses are more than just places to play—they’re economic engines driving growth in real estate and tourism alike.

If you’re ready to explore properties near Long Island’s finest golf courses, I’m here to help. As Long Island’s first A.I.-Certified Real Estate Agent™, I can provide you with the data-driven insights you need to make the right decision—whether you're searching for a luxurious home near Shinnecock or a more laid-back spot near Montauk Downs.

Contact me, Dean Miller, at Dean@TheBeaconTeam.com or visit www.TheBeaconTeam.com to start your search. Let’s find you a home where the greens are pristine, the lifestyle is unmatched, and your golf game is just a short drive away. Ready to tee up your future? Let’s do this!