Mansions, Cathedrals & Castles—The Most Stunning Buildings on Long Island

Long Island may be known for its beaches, bagels, and billionaire summer homes, but its architectural beauty deserves just as much attention. From opulent mansions that rival European estates to historic cathedrals and castles that look straight out of a fairy tale, Long Island is home to some of the most breathtaking buildings in the country. These aren’t just fancy structures—they’re proof that Long Island has been showing off long before Instagram made it cool. Whether you're a history buff, an architecture lover, or just someone who appreciates a good backdrop for social media flexing, these stunning structures are worth a visit.

1. Oheka Castle – The Ultimate Gilded Age Fantasy

If you’ve ever dreamed of living like Gatsby (minus the tragic ending), Oheka Castle in Huntington is as close as you’ll get. Built in 1919 by Otto Hermann Kahn, this French-style château is the second-largest private residence ever constructed in the U.S. Kahn wanted to outdo everyone in terms of luxury, and spoiler alert—he succeeded. Grand staircases, manicured gardens, and jaw-dropping interiors make Oheka the kind of place where you half expect to bump into old-money socialites. Over the years, it has been everything from a private estate to a military academy and now a luxury hotel and wedding venue. And if it looks familiar, that’s because it’s been featured in countless movies, TV shows, and even a Taylor Swift music video. Clearly, this place is still stealing the spotlight over a century later.

2. The Cathedral of the Incarnation – A Gothic Masterpiece That Looks Imported from Europe

Standing tall in Garden City, the Cathedral of the Incarnation is one of Long Island’s most impressive religious structures. Built in the late 19th century, this Episcopal cathedral boasts soaring spires, stunning stained glass, and intricate stonework that rivals the great cathedrals of Europe. Commissioned by Cornelia Stewart in memory of her husband, Alexander Turney Stewart (who pretty much built Garden City), the cathedral is a testament to love, faith, and having the kind of money that lets you build cathedrals. Whether you’re attending a service, admiring the architecture, or just trying to impress a date with your cultural knowledge, this spot delivers.

3. Hempstead House – A Mansion That Makes Your House Feel Tiny

Nestled within the Sands Point Preserve, Hempstead House is a 50,000-square-foot Tudor-style mansion that once belonged to the Guggenheim family. Think massive stone walls, grand halls, and libraries that make you feel like you should be solving a mystery in a classic novel. Originally built as a summer home (because apparently, the ultra-wealthy needed another house just for the warmer months), the mansion is now open to the public for tours, special events, and the occasional film shoot. So, if you ever wanted to step into a real-life Clue board, this is your chance.

4. Vanderbilt Museum and Mansion – Where Wealth Meets Science and Whales

If you want history, art, and science all wrapped up in one, the Vanderbilt Museum in Centerport is the place to be. This Spanish Revival-style mansion, built by William K. Vanderbilt II, features everything from lavish bedrooms and vintage car collections to a planetarium that adds a celestial twist to the estate. Yes, a planetarium. Because when you’re a Vanderbilt, your backyard observatory is just another flex. Overlooking the North Shore, the estate offers stunning views of the Long Island Sound, proving once again that money does buy a spectacular backyard.

5. Coe Hall at Planting Fields – A Tudor Revival Masterpiece That’ll Make You Feel Underdressed

Located in Oyster Bay, Coe Hall is an estate that looks like it was plucked right out of the English countryside. Built in the 1920s by Standard Oil heir William Robertson Coe, this Tudor Revival mansion features oak-paneled rooms, stained glass windows, and some of the most stunning gardens you’ll find on Long Island. It’s part of the Planting Fields Arboretum, which means after you’ve finished gawking at the mansion’s sheer grandeur, you can wander through acres of perfectly maintained greenery. Just be warned: after visiting this place, your home landscaping will feel painfully inadequate.

6. The Montauk Lighthouse – Long Island’s Most Iconic Beacon of Beauty

While not a mansion or cathedral, the Montauk Lighthouse is one of Long Island’s most recognizable landmarks. Commissioned by George Washington himself in 1792, this lighthouse sits at the easternmost point of Long Island and offers breathtaking panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean. It has survived wars, storms, and thousands of tourists who think climbing to the top will somehow make them more philosophical. Whether you’re into maritime history or just need a scenic excuse to get out east, Montauk Point should be on your list.

Long Island’s Architectural Show-Offs

Long Island isn’t just about suburban sprawl and overpriced brunch—it’s a place where history, art, and design collide to create some of the most stunning structures in the country. From castles and cathedrals to mansions that embody the excess of the Gilded Age, these buildings tell the story of Long Island’s past while continuing to awe visitors today.

Ready to Find Your Own Piece of Long Island’s Legacy?

Why just admire these stunning properties when you can live in a home that embodies charm, history, and timeless elegance? Whether you’re searching for a historic estate, a waterfront retreat, or a home near Long Island’s most iconic landmarks, I can help make it happen.

📩 Email me at Dean@TheBeaconTeam.com
🌐 Start your home search at www.TheBeaconTeam.com
📞 Let’s find you a home that’s as impressive as Long Island itself!