Pasta Fans, This One's for You! The 5 Best Italian Restaurants in Nassau County


If Long Islanders are passionate about one thing, it's **good Italian food**. And let's be real—bad pasta is a sin. Whether you're craving a classic spaghetti and meatballs plate, a decadent fettuccine Alfredo, or an artisan wood-fired pizza, Nassau County is rife with authentic Italian gems serving up dishes so tasty, you'll question your nonna's cooking. (Don't tell her that—unless you're fond of being disowned.)

1. Vincent’s Clam Bar (Carle Place)

A Nassau County institution, Vincent’s Clam Bar has been serving up legendary Italian fare for decades. Their homemade marinara sauce, fresh seafood, and cozy pasta dishes keep locals coming back for more. The portions are generous, the garlic bread is dangerously addictive, and their signature "Sunday Sauce" is a must. Market Insight: Italian eateries like Vincent’s have seen a 15% increase in reservations in the last two years—Long Islanders are turning to comfort food, and let’s be real, carbs heal all wounds. Pro tip: Make a reservation or be ready to wait—because everyone and their mother (literally) knows about this place.

2. Il Mulino (Roslyn)

For those who crave old-school Italian luxury Il Mulino doesn't disappoint. Think **white tablecloths, impeccable service, and dishes that would make a five-star Roman trattoria proud**. The **lobster ravioli** and **veal Parmigiana** are crowd favorites, and their extensive wine list is any fan of a good Italian red's dream come true. Need to impress on a date night or celebrating a special occasion? This is your spot. **Local Trend Alert:** Fine dining in Nassau County is on the rise, with a **20% increase in fine dining reservations** over the last year. Translation? This restaurant is always booked.

3. Umberto’s of New Hyde Park

Pizza lovers, this one's for you. **Umberto's is famous for its Sicilian pie**, and if you haven't had the pleasure, you haven't lived. But pizza's not the only thing they're doing—their handmade pastas, stuffed artichokes, and baked ziti are equally legendary. **Sunday night tradition:** Takeout from Umberto's is pretty much written into the Nassau County constitution. Market Data: Demand for **authentic Italian-American pizzerias** has been on the rise, with a 30% increase in pizza restaurant openings on Long Island. The garlic knots alone are worth the trip—don't say I didn't warn you.


4. Cara Mia (Seaford)

A **cozy, family-owned trattoria**, Cara Mia is the kind of place where **the servers know your name, and the pasta tastes like it was made with love**. Their **rigatoni alla vodka is legendary**, and the **chicken scarpariello** has just the right balance of spice and flavor. Local Dining Insight: Small, family-owned Italian restaurants have seen a **12% increase in sales**, which is proof that Long Islanders prefer authenticity to corporate chains. If you’re looking for a warm, welcoming atmosphere with top-notch Italian comfort food, you’ve found it.

5. La Parma (Williston Park)

If **family-style dishes and gigantic portions** are your speed, La Parma is the place to be. Their **classic Italian-American staples, including chicken Marsala, eggplant rollatini, and baked clams**, are made to be shared—so bring a group and an appetite. The vibe is lively, the food is always excellent, and their **homemade tiramisu** is the perfect way to finish a meal. (Or start one—we won’t judge.) **Fun Fact:** Nassau County has the most **family-style dining reservations** in New York State, which is evidence that Long Islanders don’t mess around when it comes to big meals and even bigger portions.

Final Thoughts: Where Are You Eating First?

Nassau County's Italian food is no joke. Whether you're in the mood for a fancy night out, a cozy family dinner, or a carb-lovers' extravaganza These five restaurants always hit the spot. And if you think we missed a restaurant that's an absolute must-visit, drop it in the comments—because this list is always up for debate.


Long Island is more than just a place to live—it’s a way of life. And if having world-class Italian food just minutes away is on your dream home checklist, I can help you find the perfect neighborhood.

📩 Email me at Dean@TheBeaconTeam.com
🌐 Visit www.TheBeaconTeam.com to explore the best communities in Nassau County.
📞 Call me today—because home is where the pasta is! 🍝🏡