Winter on Long Island is a real mixed bag: beautiful, snow-covered landscapes combined with ice-cold, knife-like winds that make a person question life choices with every step outside. But never fear, fellow Long Islanders, for there is warm solace in a cup, waiting for you at some of the best coffee spots across this great island.

Whether you're dodging the cold or just in dire need of caffeine, these cafes will keep your spirits-and your body temperature-just right this winter.

1. Toast Coffeehouse – Patchogue, Bay Shore, Port Jefferson

Toast Coffeehouse is not just a spot for a cup of coffee but an experience in itself. Quirky decor amalgamated with a boisterous atmosphere and killer coffee menu makes Toast a top choice amongst locals. Their Nutty Irishman Latte or the Toasted Almond are perfect winter warmers. Fun fact: Patchogue location sees brunch lines often longer than a summer Friday on the LIE, but trust us, it's worth it.

Get it with their signature Stuffed French Toast because calories don't count in winter, right?

2. North Fork Roasting Co. – Southold

Situated in the heart of Long Island's wine country, North Fork Roasting Co. serves up a coffee experience as sophisticated as the local merlots. House-roasted beans guarantee each cup is a masterpiece. Winter highlight? Their Maple Cinnamon Latte feels like a hug in a cup. The rustic vibe and fireplace make this the perfect escape from the chill-plus, it's a great excuse to explore the North Fork's winter charm.

3. Sweetie Pies on Main – Cold Spring Harbor

Sweetie Pies is where coffee meets art. This Cold Spring Harbor café feels like stepping inside of a snow globe: cozy, picturesque, and oozing warmness. A fan favorite on the menu, their Hot Chocolate Espresso Fusion brings together the richness of cocoa with the kick of espresso. Bonus: The historic hamlet's Main Street is a perfect spot for a post-coffee stroll… if you're game enough to brace the cold.

4. Sail Away Coffee Co. – Patchogue

Sail Away Coffee Co. brings a taste of Long Island's coast to your cup. Yes, they're known for their nitro cold brews-even in winter, because Long Islanders are tough-but they also nail hot drinks like their Peppermint Mocha. Their Patchogue location is super laid-back, so it's a great place to catch up on some work or simply zone out with a good book.

5. Coffee Booths – Huntington

The ideal neighborhood café, Huntington's Coffee Booths is homey, comforting, and home to some of the friendliest baristas in town, not to mention some innovative drinks-including combos. This is a locals' cold-weather favorite. Their Winter Spice Latte is highly seasonal, best paired with their fresh biscotti. Pro tip: Huntington Village is quite a vibrant scene-so this is a perfect starting point into the day of winter exploration.

6. Flux Coffee – Farmingdale

If you're serious about your coffee, then Flux is serious about you. Quality beans meet precision in brewing with every cup at this venue. This winter, don't miss their Honey Lavender Latte-it's an interesting and cozy contrast. The minimalistic interior may feel a bit cold, but with a cup of coffee in your hands, you'll feel warmth from the inside out.

7. The Witches Brew – West Hempstead

Quirky, cozy, and absolutely unforgettable, The Witches Brew is a haven for any coffee lover who takes a little bit of quirk with their cup. Its Spiced Pumpkin Latte and Winter Berry Tea Latte are just as charming as the eclectic decorations that adorn the cafe walls. And not to mention their vegan-friendly desserts-just a piece of advice: not only coffee, but an experience in itself.

8. Southdown Coffee – Huntington, Oyster Bay, Glen Cove

Southdown Coffee is all about sustainability and quality. Their ethically sourced beans and expertly crafted drinks make them a Long Island staple. This winter, their Gingerbread Latte is the holiday spirit in liquid form. With multiple locations, you're never far from one of their warm, inviting spaces.

9. Roast Coffee and Tea Trading Company – Patchogue

Artistry mingles with caffeine at Roast Coffee and Tea Trading Company. The Mocha Peppermint Latte is a winter must-have, blending chocolatey sweetness with refreshing mint. Cozy seating and several displays from local artists will make this Patchogue spot the perfect winter hideout.

10. TEND Coffee – Shirley and Patchogue

TEND Coffee is proof that organic and delicious can go hand-in-hand. Their Salted Caramel Latte is a winter favorite, balancing sweetness with a hint of salt for a truly satisfying drink. Friendly staff and a warm atmosphere make this spot feel like home—just with better coffee. Why Long Islanders Love These Spots Long Island's coffee shops are so much more than a cup of joe: they're hubs of community, creativity, and comfort. From the rustic retreats of the North Fork to the bustling village vibes of Huntington, these capture the essence of what makes Long Island special. Whether you're dodging a Nor'easter or just looking for a reason to leave the house, these coffee spots have you covered. 

Winter doesn't necessarily mean hibernation. It’s the perfect time to get out, explore Long Island’s vibrant coffee scene, and find your new favorite brew. From cozy hideaways to bustling village hubs, there’s a coffee spot here to brighten any winter day.

Ready to Make Long Island Your Home, One Coffee Shop at a Time?
Long Island isn’t just a place—it’s a lifestyle, complete with warm cups of coffee and community vibes. Whether you’re buying or selling, let me help you find your perfect spot on this amazing island.

🔗Looking to buy or sell, click here🔗